33+ “Flirty Comebacks to ‘Do You Trust Me?’ [2025]

“If trust is the game, then flirty comebacks to ‘Do you trust me?’ are your winning move.”

Let’s be real I’ve been there too. Someone leans in, drops the classic “Do you trust me?” line, and boom you’re caught between a smile and a sassy reply. That question might sound sweet, but it’s often wrapped in charm, mystery, or even a little mischief. Whether it’s your crush testing the waters or someone trying to make a bold move, your response matters.

That’s why I put this guide together to help you stay flirty, funny, and in control with the perfect comeback. From cheeky to smooth, these replies will help you answer with style and a little sparkle. Every line here is easy to understand, real to use, and fun to share.

In this article, you’ll find the best flirty comebacks to ‘Do you trust me?’—all unique, playful, and perfect for making your moment unforgettable.

1. “I’m tempted to trust you… but where’s the fun in that?”

Story: You’re being playfully skeptical.
When to Use: During teasing or flirtatious moments.
When Not to Use: If someone’s opening up seriously.
Example:
Them: “You can trust me.”
You: “I’m tempted to trust you… but where’s the fun in that?”
How to Respond: Keep the mood light and flirty.

2. “Only if you promise to make it worth my while

Story: You’re showing playful conditions.
When to Use: When you want them to step up with effort or charm.
When Not to Use: In formal or serious conversations.
Example:
Them: “Do you trust me?”
You: “Only if you promise to make it worth my while.”
How to Respond: Add a wink or playful emoji for effect.

3. “I’m not sure yet, but I’m willing to find out.”

Story: You’re open but cautious.
When to Use: When you’re starting to warm up to them.
When Not to Use: If you’re absolutely not interested.
Example:
Them: “Can I earn your trust?”
You: “I’m not sure yet, but I’m willing to find out.”
How to Respond: Let the conversation build slowly.

4. “Trust is earned, not given—care to work for it?”

Story: You’re setting playful standards.
When to Use: When you want them to show effort.
When Not to Use: If they’re looking for instant affirmation.
Example:
Them: “Just trust me.”
You: “Trust is earned, not given—care to work for it?”
How to Respond: Encourage them to impress you.

5. “How about I trust you if you promise to keep me entertained?”

Story: You’re linking trust with fun.
When to Use: When you want to keep things upbeat and humorous.
When Not to Use: If the person seems down or serious.
Example:
Them: “Do you trust me?”
You: “How about I trust you if you promise to keep me entertained?”
How to Respond: Tease them with a fun challenge or question

6. “Convince me. I like a good story.”

Story: You’re inviting them to earn your trust with charm.
When to Use: During playful banter or flirting.
When Not to Use: When you’re too tired for long chats.
Example:
Them: “Why don’t you trust me yet?”
You: “Convince me. I like a good story.”
How to Respond: Say it with a smile or playful tone.

7. “I’m suspicious… but in a cute way.”

Story: You’re being funny while expressing mild doubt.
When to Use: When teasing or joking around.
When Not to Use: If the other person is taking things seriously.
Example:
Them: “You really don’t trust me?”
You: “I’m suspicious… but in a cute way.”
How to Respond: Use a flirty emoji or raised eyebrow look.

8. “I trust you… about as far as I can throw you.”

Story: Classic funny phrase with flirty undertones.
When to Use: When joking about trust.
When Not to Use: In serious or sensitive conversations.
Example:
Them: “So, you trust me?”
You: “I trust you… about as far as I can throw you.”
How to Respond: Laugh it off and let them prove you wrong.

9. “Let’s just say you’re on trial… and I’m the judge.”

Story: You’re adding fun drama to the conversation.
When to Use: When you want to playfully assess them.
When Not to Use: If they’re shy or uncomfortable.
Example:
Them: “Can I win your trust?”
You: “Let’s just say you’re on trial… and I’m the judge.”
How to Respond: Continue with playful “courtroom” talk.

10. “Only if you swear to make me laugh daily.”

Story: You’re setting lighthearted conditions.
When to Use: When you want to keep the mood cheerful.
When Not to Use: If they’re in a serious mindset.
Example:
Them: “Want to take a chance on me?”
You: “Only if you swear to make me laugh daily.”
How to Respond: Challenge them with a joke or pun.

See also: “Smart & Safe Ways to Respond to a Monkey”

11. “Maybe I trust you… just don’t mess it up.”

Story: You’re offering a gentle warning with a smile.
When to Use: If you want to sound mysterious yet playful.
When Not to Use: If they already feel unsure.
Example:
Them: “You trust me now?”
You: “Maybe I trust you… just don’t mess it up.”
How to Respond: Give a teasing wink or emoji.

12. “I’m watching you… with curious eyes.”

Story: A light, flirty twist on being observant.
When to Use: When you want to stay mysterious.
When Not to Use: If they don’t enjoy playful teasing.
Example:
Them: “You still don’t believe me?”
You: “I’m watching you… with curious eyes.”
How to Respond: Send a silly GIF or emoji with it.

13. “If I trust you, do I get snacks too?”

Story: A cute and random way to keep it fun.
When to Use: In casual, silly convos.
When Not to Use: When the topic is serious.
Example:
Them: “Just give me your trust already.”
You: “If I trust you, do I get snacks too?”
How to Respond: Follow up with your favorite snack emoji.

14. “I’ll trust you when you pass my vibe check.”

Story: You’re keeping up with internet slang humorously.
When to Use: When you’re casually chatting.
When Not to Use: In older or formal conversations.
Example:
Them: “How do I earn your trust?”
You: “I’ll trust you when you pass my vibe check.”
How to Respond: Make it a game—“Vibe check in 3…2…1…”

15. “You’re suspiciously charming. I’ll allow it.”

Story: You’re complimenting them with a twist.
When to Use: When they’re obviously trying to charm you.
When Not to Use: If you’re feeling annoyed or distant.
Example:
Them: “What do you think of me?”
You: “You’re suspiciously charming. I’ll allow it.”
How to Respond: Let your expression do the talking too.

16. “Trust fall? Nah. Trust flirt.”

Story: You’re turning a phrase into something cute.
When to Use: When joking about emotional stuff.
When Not to Use: If they don’t get the reference.
Example:
Them: “Would you do a trust fall with me?”
You: “Trust fall? Nah. Trust flirt.”
How to Respond: Make it clear you’re being cheeky.

17. “That depends. Are you planning on stealing my heart?”

Story: You’re mixing trust talk with flirtation.
When to Use: When they ask something deep or sweet.
When Not to Use: If you’re not interested.
Example:
Them: “Can I earn your trust?”
You: “That depends. Are you planning on stealing my heart?”
How to Respond: Be playful and dramatic with i

18. “I’m trusting you… with snacks, secrets, and my sass.”

Story: A playful list of what you bring to the table.
When to Use: In a lighthearted moment.
When Not to Use: When discussing real vulnerability.
Example:
Them: “Can I be your safe space?”
You: “I’m trusting you… with snacks, secrets, and my sass.”
How to Respond: Laugh and add something funny to the list.

19. “I trust you like I trust Wi-Fi — until it lags.”

Story: A funny metaphor for fragile trust.
When to Use: In techy or casual conversations.
When Not to Use: With people who overanalyze jokes.
Example:
Them: “You don’t trust me?”
You: “I trust you like I trust Wi-Fi — until it lags.”
How to Respond: Use a buffering emoji or joke.

20. “Okay, but only if you pinky promise… and mean it.”

Story: A sweet, childlike way to build trust.
When to Use: When you’re feeling playful.
When Not to Use: If they’re not into cutesy talk.
Example:
Them: “Trust me this once?”
You: “Okay, but only if you pinky promise… and mean it.”
How to Respond: Hold out your pinky or send a pinky emoji.

See also: ”Best Ways to Reply When Your Crush Says Thank You”

21. “My trust isn’t cheap, but you’re kinda worth it.”

Story: You’re making them feel special in a fun way.
When to Use: When things are moving forward.
When Not to Use: If you’re unsure about the person.
Example:
Them: “Do I earn some points now?”
You: “My trust isn’t cheap, but you’re kinda worth it.”
How to Respond: Flash a playful grin or shrug emoji.

22. “If I trust you, you owe me a coffee date.”

Story: You’re turning trust into an excuse for fun.
When to Use: When you’re ready to take things up a notch.
When Not to Use: If you’re not ready for a meet-up.
Example:
Them: “Do I have your trust now?”
You: “If I trust you, you owe me a coffee date.”
How to Respond: Add a wink or coffee emoji.

23. “You seem trustworthy… suspiciously so.”

Story: You’re being humorous while low-key flirty.
When to Use: When someone is being extra nice.
When Not to Use: If you don’t know their vibe yet.
Example:
Them: “I’d never hurt you.”
You: “You seem trustworthy… suspiciously so.”
How to Respond: Smirk or narrow your eyes jokingly.

24. “I trust you more than I trust my GPS — and that’s rare.”

Story: A modern compliment with a laugh.
When to Use: During road trips or techy convos.
When Not to Use: In totally serious discussions.
Example:
Them: “Really? You trust me?”
You: “I trust you more than I trust my GPS — and that’s rare.”
How to Respond: Add a map or location emoji for humor.

25. “You earned one trust token. Spend it wisely.”

Story: Turning trust into a cute game.
When to Use: When they’ve done something nice or sweet.
When Not to Use: If the tone isn’t fun.
Example:
Them: “Did I do good?”
You: “You earned one trust token. Spend it wisely.”
How to Respond: Pretend it’s a collectible prize.

26. “I trust you to keep this conversation intriguing.”

Story: You want to keep the playful banter going while giving them a little credit.
When to Use: When the convo is fun and mysterious.
When Not to Use: If you’re in a serious or emotional chat.
Example:
Them: “Do you trust me?”
You: “I trust you to keep this conversation intriguing.”
How to Respond: Say it with a smile and a curious tone.

27. “Trust me, I’m full of surprises.”

Story: You want to flip the script and add a flirty twist.
When to Use: If you want to tease them right back.
When Not to Use: If they’re being super sincere.
Example:
Them: “Can you trust me?”
You: “Trust me, I’m full of surprises.”
How to Respond: Say it confidently, with playful energy.

28. “I trust you enough to see where this goes.”

Story: You’re opening up a little but still keeping it mysterious.
When to Use: When you’re curious but cautious.
When Not to Use: If you’re completely uninterested.
Example:
Them: “Do you trust me?”
You: “I trust you enough to see where this goes.”
How to Respond: Speak with sincerity, but keep a playful tone.

29. “Trust is earned, but I’m willing to start.”

Story: You’re giving them a chance without giving away too much.
When to Use: To show openness with boundaries.
When Not to Use: If you feel pressured.
Example:
Them: “Do you trust me?”
You: “Trust is earned, but I’m willing to start.”
How to Respond: Be calm and genuine, with a soft smile.

30. “I trust you to keep the sparks flying.”

Story: You’re turning up the heat in a cheeky way.
When to Use: When the chemistry is strong.
When Not to Use: If you’re unsure about continuing.
Example:
Them: “Do you trust me?”
You: “I trust you to keep the sparks flying.”
How to Respond: Say it with a flirtatious look and some spark

31. “I trust you… for now.”

Story: You’re teasing while keeping your guard up just a little.
When to Use: When you want to play it cool.
When Not to Use: If they need reassurance.
Example:
Them: “Do you trust me?”
You: “I trust you… for now.”
How to Respond: Say it with a smirk and a little eyebrow raise.

See also: Smart Replies to ‘I’ll Keep That in Mind’

32. “Sure, but only if you don’t get me into trouble.”

Story: You’re making it fun and mischievous.
When to Use: When the vibe is light and adventurous.
When Not to Use: If things are turning serious.
Example:
Them: “Do you trust me?”
You: “Sure, but only if you don’t get me into trouble.”
How to Respond: Add a giggle or wink for effect.

33. “Let’s just say I’m curious enough to risk it.”

Story: You’re showing interest with a bold edge.
When to Use: If you’re enjoying the mystery.
When Not to Use: If you don’t want to take any chances.
Example:
Them: “Do you trust me?”
You: “Let’s just say I’m curious enough to risk it.”
How to Respond: Keep your voice soft but intriguing.

34. “You just made my day!”

Story: Their question or flirt made your mood lighter.
When to Use: After a compliment or sweet line.
When Not to Use: If you didn’t actually feel anything.
Example:
Crush: “You’re so thoughtful.”
You: “You just made my day!”
How to Respond: Be genuinely happy, maybe even blush a little.

35. “I guess I trust you… but don’t make me regret it.”

Story: You’re giving them a chance but setting expectations.
When to Use: If you’re cautiously interested.
When Not to Use: If you’re feeling fully confident.
Example:
Them: “Do you trust me?”
You: “I guess I trust you… but don’t make me regret it.”
How to Respond: Say it seriously but with a teasing tone.

Top Editor Choice Responses

• “Only if you’re not leading me off a cliff.”
  
• “With my heart? Maybe. With my snacks? Never.”
  
• “Trust you? I barely trust myself around you.”
  
• “Depends… what are you asking me to do?”
  
• “I trust you… to keep flirting like that.”
  
• “I trust you—with my smile at least.”
  
• “As long as it includes cuddles, yes.”
  
• “Sure, but I’m keeping one eye open.”
  
• “Only if you promise to catch me.”
  
• “Not sure… do you deserve it?”
  
• “I trust you—until proven flirty.”
  
• “Let’s test that trust… over coffee?”
  
• “I trust you… to drive me  to make one’s blood boil.”
  
• “Yes, but don’t make me regret it.”
  
• “Try me and find out.”

Conclusion

Flirting is all about timing, tone, and a little boldness. When someone asks, “Do you trust me?” it opens the perfect door for a cheeky, sweet, or teasing comeback. The lines above can help you keep the spark alive, show your playful side, or even deepen the connection.

Whether you’re chatting online, texting late at night, or sitting close in person, these responses can turn a simple question into a moment of real chemistry. Don’t be afraid to mix humor with a hint of mystery. In the end, trust can grow—especially with a wink and the right words.