A little flirty banter never hurt anyone! When someone says, You’re too good for me, it’s often a mix of modest charm and a sweet compliment. But why stop there? A clever reply can turn the moment into something witty, playful, and full of humor.
I love keeping conversations light-hearted and engaging, and the best way to do that is with a fun comeback. Whether you want to tease, flirt, or just add some lively energy, having the right response makes all the difference.
In this article, you’ll find the best replies that add charm, spark, and a little fun to your conversations!
Why Flirty and Witty Responses Matter
Flirty and witty responses add excitement and energy to conversations. They make interactions more engaging, turning simple moments into playful exchanges that leave a lasting impression. A well-timed remark shows confidence, humor, and charm, making the conversation feel more light-hearted and fun.
When someone says, You’re too good for me, responding with a clever comeback keeps things interesting. Instead of letting the conversation end with a simple thank you, you can turn it into something lively and memorable. Whether you’re flirting back or just having fun, these responses show personality and keep the spark alive.
1. Maybe, but I think we’re a perfect match.
Story:
Sarah and Mike are chatting at a party. Mike playfully mentions that Sarah is too good for him. Sarah responds confidently with, Maybe, but I think we’re a perfect match. She’s clearly interested, adding a playful twist to the conversation.
When to Use:
This response works well when you’re feeling confident and want to show you’re equally interested. It’s a fun and flirty way to keep the conversation going.
When Not to Use:
Avoid this if you’re not interested in the person. It can give off the wrong impression if you’re not ready to flirt or engage.
Example:
Mike: You’re too good for me.
Sarah: Maybe, but I think we’re a perfect match.
How to Respond 🗣️
If you want to keep the flirty vibe going, try responding with something playful like, I think you just need to catch up! or We’ll make the perfect team!
2. Good thing I have a knack for finding perfect matches.
Story:
Liam tells Emily that she’s too good for him. Emily, feeling cheeky, responds with, Good thing I have a knack for finding perfect matches. She’s not shy about showing her interest while adding a light, flirty touch.
When to Use:
This is a great response when you’re feeling confident and want to tease someone in a playful way. It shows you’re quick with a comeback and aren’t afraid to flirt.
When Not to Use:
If the person is being too serious or you’re unsure if they’ll take your response well, it’s best to hold off.
Example:
Liam: You’re too good for me.
Emily: Good thing I have a knack for finding perfect matches.
How to Respond 🗣️
If they laugh and seem interested, you can reply with, So, do you think we’re a perfect fit? or Looks like we might just be the perfect match!
3. I guess that makes me your upgrade.
Story:
Rachel and Ben are having a playful conversation, and Ben says, You’re too good for me. Rachel, with a smirk, responds, I guess that makes me your upgrade. She’s confident and playful, and Ben enjoys the banter.
When to Use:
This response is ideal when you want to show confidence and a bit of humor. It’s a fun way to turn the compliment into a light-hearted exchange.
When Not to Use:
Avoid using this line if you think the other person might take it too seriously or misinterpret it as arrogance.
Example:
Ben: You’re too good for me.
Rachel: I guess that makes me your upgrade.
How to Respond 🗣️
If they laugh, you could follow up with, I’ll take that as a compliment! or Hope you’re ready for the upgrade!
4. I don’t believe in being ‘too good’—just being myself.
Story:
Jessica and Tom are chatting, and Tom says, You’re too good for me. Jessica smiles and responds, I don’t believe in being ‘too good’—just being myself. She’s confident and genuine, showing Tom that she’s just comfortable with who she is.
When to Use:
This response is perfect when you want to keep things grounded and show that you’re not into boasting. It’s a great way to stay humble while still accepting a compliment.
When Not to Use:
If the conversation feels too serious or if you’re unsure how the other person will react to your honesty, this might not be the best choice.
Example:
Tom: You’re too good for me.
Jessica: I don’t believe in being ‘too good’—just being myself.
How to Respond 🗣️
If they respond positively, you could say something like, I’m just glad we get along! or Being myself works out just fine.
5. Well, you’re pretty amazing yourself.
Story:
Ethan and Claire are hanging out, and Ethan says, You’re too good for me. Claire, with a smile, responds, Well, you’re pretty amazing yourself. She keeps it sweet and flattering while showing Ethan she’s interested too.
When to Use:
This line works great when you want to return the compliment in a sweet and humble way. It keeps the conversation warm and flattering.
When Not to Use:
If you’re not genuinely interested, this might come across as insincere. Only use it when you mean it.
Example:
Ethan: You’re too good for me.
Claire: Well, you’re pretty amazing yourself.
How to Respond 🗣️
If they smile back, you can follow up with, You’re a pretty awesome person, too! or I think we’re both pretty great!
6. If that’s true, then I must be lucky.
Story:
Alex tells Olivia, You’re too good for me. Olivia grins and responds, If that’s true, then I must be lucky. She keeps it light and playful while showing she’s flattered by the compliment.
When to Use:
This response works well when you want to flirt back in a way that’s fun and shows you’re humble. It turns the conversation into a back-and-forth of compliments.
When Not to Use:
If you feel like the person might not take it well or if you’re not interested, it’s best to skip this one.
Example:
Alex: You’re too good for me.
Olivia: If that’s true, then I must be lucky.
How to Respond 🗣️
If they seem to like your response, you can reply with, Guess we’re both lucky then! or I’m feeling pretty lucky, too!
Learn More: Best Response to What Rock Have You Been Hiding Under?
7. Let’s just say we balance each other out.
Story:
Sophie and David are enjoying a casual chat. David says, You’re too good for me. Sophie, with a playful grin, responds, Let’s just say we balance each other out. She’s keeping it fun and showing that she enjoys the conversation.
When to Use:
This response is great for when you want to show chemistry and keep things light. It suggests that both of you have something special to bring to the table.
When Not to Use:
If you feel like the other person is taking the compliment too seriously, this might not be the best choice.
Example:
David: You’re too good for me.
Sophie: Let’s just say we balance each other out.
How to Respond 🗣️
If they laugh, you could reply with, I think we make a pretty great pair! or That’s what makes us work so well together!
8. Well, I think you’re just right for me.
Story:
John and Lily are chatting, and John says, You’re too good for me. Lily smiles warmly and responds, Well, I think you’re just right for me. It’s sweet, sincere, and shows that Lily values their connection.
When to Use:
This line is perfect when you want to show someone you appreciate them and that you’re genuinely interested. It adds warmth to the conversation.
When Not to Use:
If you’re not ready to get serious or you’re unsure about your feelings, it might be best to avoid this response.
Example:
John: You’re too good for me.
Lily: Well, I think you’re just right for me.
How to Respond 🗣️
If they smile, you can follow up with, I think we’re a good match! or I’m glad we feel that way about each other!
9. I must be your personal hero then.
Story:
Zoe and Jake are joking around, and Jake says, You’re too good for me. Zoe, with a wink, replies, I must be your personal hero then. It’s a playful response that adds humor to the exchange.
When to Use:
Use this line when you want to keep things light and fun, adding a bit of cheeky humor to the conversation. It’s perfect for when you’re both in a playful mood.
When Not to Use:
If you’re not in the mood to joke around or if the other person might not appreciate the humor, this might not be the best choice.
Example:
Jake: You’re too good for me.
Zoe: I must be your personal hero then.
How to Respond 🗣️
If they laugh, you can reply with, That’s right! You’re welcome! or Glad to be your hero!
10. Good thing I’m not looking for perfection.
Story:
Chris and Natalie are chatting casually, and Chris says, You’re too good for me. Natalie smiles and responds, Good thing I’m not looking for perfection. It’s a fun, grounded reply that keeps things relaxed and shows she’s just enjoying the conversation.
When to Use:
This is a great response when you want to keep things easy-going and show that you’re not all about perfection. It’s a down-to-earth reply that adds humor.
When Not to Use:
Avoid using this if the other person is looking for something more serious or if the tone of the conversation is shifting to something deeper.
Example:
Chris: You’re too good for me.
Natalie: Good thing I’m not looking for perfection.
How to Respond 🗣️
If they smile or laugh, try responding with, Imperfectly perfect, right? or I’m just enjoying being here with you.
11. You must have a pretty good taste then.
Story:
Ryan tells Lily, You’re too good for me. Lily, with a playful smirk, replies, You must have pretty good taste then. It turns the compliment around and makes Ryan feel appreciated too.
When to Use:
This works great when you want to be flirty but also acknowledge the compliment in a fun way.
When Not to Use:
If the person is being overly self-deprecating, this response might not lighten the mood.
Example:
Ryan: You’re too good for me.
Lily: You must have a pretty good taste then.
How to Respond:
They might laugh or smile, so you can continue with, I mean, you picked me, right?
12. Well, I’m glad I’m your type.
Story:
Ethan tells Sarah, You’re too good for me. Sarah grins and says, Well, I’m glad I’m your type. This keeps the conversation lighthearted and flirty.
When to Use:
When you want to accept the compliment while still keeping it fun and playful.
When Not to Use:
If you don’t actually like the person that way, this response might give them the wrong idea.
Example:
Ethan: You’re too good for me.
Sarah: Well, I’m glad I’m your type.
How to Respond:
If they continue the flirt, you can say, I think we make a great match.
13. If that’s true, then I’m doing something right.
Story:
Jake tells Mia, You’re too good for me. Mia, feeling confident, responds, If that’s true, then I’m doing something right. It shows confidence and appreciation.
When to Use:
When you want to accept the compliment while keeping the conversation engaging.
When Not to Use:
If the other person seems genuinely insecure, it may be better to reassure them instead.
Example:
Jake: You’re too good for me.
Mia: If that’s true, then I’m doing something right.
How to Respond:
Follow up with a smile and say, And I plan on keeping it that way.
14. I’m just glad I get to be with you.
Story:
Nathan tells Emily, You’re too good for me. Emily, feeling sentimental, replies, I’m just glad I get to be with you. It makes Nathan feel valued and reassured.
When to Use:
When you want to be sweet and show appreciation for the relationship.
When Not to Use:
If you’re not that serious about the person, this might send mixed signals.
Example:
Nathan: You’re too good for me.
Emily: I’m just glad I get to be with you.
How to Respond:
If they smile, you can add, That’s all that matters.
15. I think we’re both lucky in this situation.
Story:
Daniel tells Sophia, You’re too good for me. Sophia warmly replies, I think we’re both lucky in this situation. It reassures Daniel while keeping things balanced.
When to Use:
When you want to keep things equal and make the other person feel special too.
When Not to Use:
If the person is making a joke, this might come off too serious.
Example:
Daniel: You’re too good for me.
Sophia: I think we’re both lucky in this situation.
How to Respond:
Follow up with, I’m just happy we found each other.
Learn More: Best and Clever Responses to “Are You Hungry?”
16. You’re not too shabby yourself.
Story:
Chris tells Ava, You’re too good for me. Ava winks and responds, You’re not too shabby yourself. It keeps the exchange light and fun.
When to Use:
When you want to keep things playful and avoid making it too serious.
When Not to Use:
If the other person is feeling genuinely insecure, this might not be the best reassurance.
Example:
Chris: You’re too good for me.
Ava: You’re not too shabby yourself.
How to Respond:
Follow up with, Guess that makes us a great pair.
17. I think we’re both just right.
Story:
Mason tells Olivia, You’re too good for me. Olivia softly replies, I think we’re both just right. This response reassures Mason while keeping the conversation warm.
When to Use:
When you want to gently reassure someone while maintaining a heartfelt connection.
When Not to Use:
If you want to keep things light and flirty, this might be a bit too serious.
Example:
Mason: You’re too good for me.
Olivia: I think we’re both just right.
How to Respond:
Follow up with, And that’s what matters most.
18. Well, I like what I see.
Story:
Liam tells Grace, You’re too good for me. Grace smirks and responds, Well, I like what I see. This keeps the conversation flirtatious and engaging.
When to Use:
When you want to be direct and flirty.
When Not to Use:
If the person is looking for a deep, emotional response, this might not be the best choice.
Example:
Liam: You’re too good for me.
Grace: Well, I like what I see.
How to Respond:
If they laugh, follow up with, Guess we’re a good match.
19. Good thing I don’t believe in limits.
Story:
Zach tells Chloe, You’re too good for me. Chloe grins and responds, Good thing I don’t believe in limits. This keeps the conversation confident and fun.
When to Use:
When you want to be bold and playful.
When Not to Use:
If the person is making a serious comment, this might not fit the tone.
Example:
Zach: You’re too good for me.
Chloe: Good thing I don’t believe in limits.
How to Respond:
Follow up with, I think we’ll do just fine.
20. I’m just happy to be here with you.
Story:
Eric tells Hannah, You’re too good for me. Hannah smiles and says, I’m just happy to be here with you. It makes Eric feel appreciated and valued.
When to Use:
When you want to keep things simple, heartfelt, and sincere.
When Not to Use:
If the moment calls for humor, this might come off too sentimental.
Example:
Eric: You’re too good for me.
Hannah: I’m just happy to be here with you.
How to Respond:
If they smile, follow up with, That’s all that matters.
21. Well, I guess we’re both lucky then.
Story:
Liam and Emma are talking after they’ve just had a successful collaboration at work. They both feel good about the outcome and are complimenting each other on their teamwork. It’s a moment of mutual appreciation.
When to Use:
This phrase is great when acknowledging shared good fortune or success. Use it when both parties feel fortunate or happy about the situation, especially after achieving something together.
When Not to Use:
Avoid using it when there’s a situation of one person being more fortunate than the other. It wouldn’t fit in serious conversations where you want to highlight individual accomplishments rather than a mutual exchange.
Example:
Liam: We nailed this project! It turned out amazing.
Emma: Well, I guess we’re both lucky then.
How to Respond 🗣️
You can respond with, Yeah, we make a great team! or I feel lucky to have worked with you on this. It keeps the positive energy going and shows your appreciation for the collaboration.
22. I think you’re pretty amazing too.
Story:
Olivia tells James that she admires his creative skills. James, feeling flattered, wants to return the compliment and let her know he thinks the same of her.
When to Use:
This phrase works when you want to reciprocate a compliment, especially in casual, friendly exchanges. It shows genuine admiration and appreciation for someone.
When Not to Use:
Don’t use it if you don’t truly feel that way or if the context is too formal for casual compliments. It’s best used in friendly, warm conversations.
Example:
Olivia: I love the way you designed that ad. You’re really talented.
James: I think you’re pretty amazing too.
How to Respond 🗣️
You could reply with, That means a lot, thank you! or We’re both pretty amazing, aren’t we?
Learn More: Funny and Creative Answers to ‘What’s Your Superpower?
23. You’re just right in my book.
Story:
Chris has just spent the day with Sarah, and they’ve had an amazing time. As the evening winds down, Chris tells Sarah that he’s enjoyed their time together and finds her to be exactly what he was hoping for.
When to Use:
This is a great phrase to use when you want to express how much you appreciate someone, particularly in a more personal or intimate setting. It shows that you’re fully content with them and the connection.
When Not to Use:
Avoid this in overly formal situations or when you don’t know the person well enough. It’s more suitable for personal or romantic exchanges.
Example:
Chris: You’ve made this day unforgettable, Sarah. You’re just right in my book.
Sarah: That’s so sweet, Chris. I’m glad we had such a great time!
How to Respond 🗣️
Sarah could respond with, I feel the same way! or I’m glad I’m just right for you.
24. I wouldn’t want it any other way.
Story:
Zoe and Jack are on a hiking trip, and despite some challenges along the way, they’ve managed to enjoy the experience together. Zoe is smiling, thinking about how everything has gone so well.
When to Use:
Use this phrase when you’re expressing satisfaction with a situation and wouldn’t change a thing. It shows you’re happy with how things turned out, even if there were bumps along the way.
When Not to Use:
Avoid using this phrase when you’re dissatisfied or when you actually wish something were different. It’s meant to convey contentment with how things are.
Example:
Zoe: That was tough, but I’m glad we pushed through it.
Jack: Yeah, I wouldn’t want it any other way.
How to Respond 🗣️
A good response could be, Exactly! It was perfect just like this or I’m glad we made it through together.
25. Well, you’re exactly what I’m looking for.
Story:
Mia and Alex are discussing a new work partnership. Mia is impressed by Alex’s skills and personality, realizing that he’s just what she needed for the project.
When to Use:
This phrase is ideal when you’ve found someone who perfectly fits your expectations, whether personally or professionally. It’s a compliment that shows genuine appreciation.
When Not to Use:
Don’t use this if you’re just meeting someone or if you’re not genuinely impressed. It’s best for situations where you feel someone is the ideal match for something you need.
Example:
Mia: I’m looking for someone who’s organized, creative, and motivated. You seem to have all those qualities.
Alex: Well, you’re exactly what I’m looking for.
How to Respond 🗣️
Alex could respond with, I’m glad to hear that! or It’s great to be a perfect match!
26. I think we make a great team.
Story:
Ella and Noah just finished working on a project together. It was a huge success, and they both feel proud of what they accomplished.
When to Use:
This phrase is perfect after working together successfully on something. It shows teamwork and highlights the collaborative effort between two people.
When Not to Use:
Avoid it if the collaboration was unsuccessful or if one person did most of the work. It’s best used in positive, successful scenarios.
Example:
Ella: We got that project done on time and beyond expectations!
Noah: I think we make a great team.
How to Respond 🗣️
A response like, I agree, we did awesome! or I couldn’t have asked for a better partner! keeps the momentum of the positive exchange going.
27. I guess that’s why I’m here.
Story:
Rachel and Tom are discussing the reason Rachel joined a new initiative at work. She believes her skills are the perfect fit for the team.
When to Use:
This phrase works well when you’re explaining your purpose for being in a specific situation or environment. It reflects confidence and understanding of your role.
When Not to Use:
Don’t use it in situations where you’re unsure of your purpose or when you’re not fully committed to the task at hand. It’s meant to convey certainty.
Example:
Rachel: I’m here to help out with the marketing campaign because I have the right experience for it.
Tom: I guess that’s why I’m here too.
How to Respond 🗣️
Rachel could say, Exactly, we both have something valuable to offer! or We make a great team with our skills.
28. I like to think we balance each other out.
Story:
Sophia and Lucas are talking about how well they complement each other’s personalities. They have different strengths but work well together as friends.
When to Use:
This phrase is great when you want to express how two people bring different qualities to a relationship but together create balance. It shows harmony and respect for each other’s differences.
When Not to Use:
Avoid using it if the balance isn’t actually there, or if one person feels they are carrying more of the load.
Example:
Sophia: You’re more of a risk-taker, and I’m more cautious, but we make it work.
Lucas: I like to think we balance each other out.
How to Respond 🗣️
Lucas could reply, Exactly, that’s what makes us such a great pair! or I couldn’t agree more.
29. You’re making me blush!
Story:
Ava and James are having a lighthearted conversation, and James gives Ava a compliment that’s so sweet it causes her to blush.
When to Use:
This phrase is great for playful or romantic conversations. It’s used when someone gives you a compliment that’s flattering or makes you feel shy in a fun way.
When Not to Use:
Don’t use it if the compliment is unwelcome or makes you uncomfortable. It’s meant for light, positive interactions.
Example:
James: You look stunning today, Ava.
Ava: You’re making me blush!
How to Respond 🗣️
James could say, I’m glad I could make you smile! or You deserve all the compliments!
30. Maybe, but I think we’re both pretty great.
Story:
Ben and Lily are discussing a recent challenge they faced at work, and while Ben is modest, Lily points out that they both handled it well.
When to Use:
This phrase is useful when you want to acknowledge a challenge but also highlight the strengths of both individuals involved. It shows confidence without being boastful.
When Not to Use:
Avoid using it when one person did most of the work or when the situation didn’t go well at all. It’s best used in balanced, positive scenarios.
Example:
Ben: It wasn’t easy, but we managed to finish the project.
Lily: Maybe, but I think we’re both pretty great.
How to Respond 🗣️
Ben could say, We make a solid team or I agree, we both brought something important to the table.
31. I never knew I needed this until now.
Story:
Emma and Ryan are trying a new hobby together—pottery. At first, Emma wasn’t sure if she would enjoy it, but as she shapes the clay, she realizes how therapeutic and fun it is. She looks at Ryan and shares her realization.
When to Use:
This phrase is great when you discover something unexpectedly valuable or enjoyable. It can apply to experiences, friendships, relationships, or new habits.
When Not to Use:
Avoid using it sarcastically or in situations where the discovery isn’t actually meaningful. It should be used sincerely.
Example:
Emma: I wasn’t sure about this at first, but I love it now.
Ryan: I never knew I needed this until now.
How to Respond 🗣️
Emma could say, Same here! Let’s do this more often. or Right? This is exactly what I needed.
32. You always know just what to say.
Story:
Liam is feeling down after a long day at work. His friend, Sophie, sends him a message reminding him of all the good things he has accomplished. Her words instantly lift his mood, making him smile.
When to Use:
This is perfect for moments when someone says something that perfectly fits the situation, whether it’s comforting, encouraging, or humorous.
When Not to Use:
Don’t use it if the person’s words didn’t actually help or if you’re being sarcastic. It’s meant to be genuine and appreciative.
Example:
Liam: I don’t think I did well today.
Sophie: You did your best, and that’s enough. I’m proud of you.
Liam: You always know just what to say.
How to Respond 🗣️
Sophie could reply with, That’s what friends are for! or I just say what I feel.
Learn More: Best Replies to When Someone Asks to Smash
33. I think we understand each other perfectly.
Story:
Jack and Olivia are discussing their travel plans, and without even saying much, they both know exactly what the other wants. Their synergy makes the planning effortless.
When to Use:
This phrase is ideal when you and someone else are on the same wavelength, whether it’s in a friendship, relationship, or teamwork.
When Not to Use:
Avoid using it if there’s confusion or if you’re actually not aligned. It’s best for moments of true understanding.
Example:
Jack: I was thinking we should go somewhere with beaches and good food.
Olivia: Exactly what I was thinking!
Jack: I think we understand each other perfectly.
How to Respond 🗣️
Olivia could say, Always! We make a great team. or It’s like we share a brain.
34. I wouldn’t trade this for anything.
Story:
Ethan and Mia are sitting by the campfire, watching the stars. It’s a simple yet beautiful moment, and Ethan expresses how much he appreciates it.
When to Use:
This phrase is great when you’re fully content with a moment or experience and wouldn’t want anything different. It’s an expression of gratitude and satisfaction.
When Not to Use:
Avoid saying it if you’re not truly happy at the moment or if there’s something you’d rather be doing.
Example:
Mia: This is so peaceful.
Ethan: Yeah. I wouldn’t trade this for anything.
How to Respond 🗣️
Mia could say, Me neither. This is perfect. or I feel the same way.
35. You’re the best part of my day.
Story:
Sophia and Daniel meet up after a long workday. Despite the stress and exhaustion, being with each other makes everything feel better.
When to Use:
Use this phrase when someone brings joy to your day, whether it’s a friend, family member, or partner. It’s a heartfelt compliment.
When Not to Use:
Don’t use it if it’s not true or if it might come across as insincere. It should be said with genuine emotion.
Example:
Sophia: Long day?
Daniel: Yeah, but you’re the best part of my day.
How to Respond 🗣️
Sophia replied, That’s so sweet! You’re mine too. or You just made my day even better.
Top Editor’s Choice Responses to You’re Too Good for Me
- Oh, stop it! We both bring something special to the table.
- Nah, we’re just right for each other.
- Don’t be silly—you’re amazing, too!
- Well, I do set high standards—but you meet them perfectly.
- I think you underestimate how incredible you are.
- You’re just saying that because you don’t see yourself the way I do.
- That’s funny—I was about to say the same about you!
- That’s nonsense. We’re both lucky to have each other.
- If I’m that good, it’s because I have you in my life.
- Oh, come on. You’re my perfect match.
- We’re both pretty awesome. Let’s agree on that.
- If I’m too good for you, then you’re just perfect for me.
- You make me better, so I’d say we’re even.
- I don’t believe in ‘too good’—I believe in ‘just right.’
- Well, I guess you’re just lucky then! 😉
Conclusion
When someone says, You’re too good for me, it can come from a place of admiration, insecurity, or even playfulness. The way you respond can shape the conversation and strengthen your bond. Whether you choose to reassure them with kindness, add a playful twist, or challenge their perspective with confidence, the key is to make them feel valued and appreciated.
Relationships thrive on mutual respect and understanding, so let your response reflect the connection you share. At the end of the day, it’s not about who’s too good for whom it’s about growing together. 💙
I’m Lily Hart, the Admin behind the engaging responses at SayStyles.com! With a knack for blending wit and warmth, I turn every piece of writing into something memorable. From clever advice to fun comebacks, I’m here to make sure every response leaves you smiling and thinking.
